The Top Pizza Restaurants in Hawaii - A Local’s Guide to the Best Slices in the Islands

Hawaii’s pizza scene continues to evolve, shaped by artisan techniques, fresh island ingredients, and a culinary culture that blends influences from around the world. After spending time on every major island and tasting standout slices across Maui, Oahu, Kauai, and the Big Island, these eleven restaurants represent the best of what the islands have to offer. Each brings a sense of place, community, and craftsmanship that makes pizza in Hawaii far more memorable than visitors expect.

1. Point Break Pizza — Maalaea, Maui

What makes this spot memorable is how seamlessly it fits into life around the Maalaea Harbor area. Even though the address falls under Wailuku, the experience feels much closer to the laid-back energy of Maalaea, where ocean breezes, fishing boats, and condo communities create a unique pocket of South Maui. The pizzas come out with a beautifully charred crust, generous toppings, and a comfortable familiarity that resonates with residents of nearby neighborhoods like Kihei and Maalaea.

Address: 1790 W Kaahumanu Ave, Wailuku, HI 96793
Phone: (808) 243-7770
Island: Maui

2. Koloa Pizza Kitchen + Bar — Koloa, Kauai

Evenings on Kauai’s South Shore often drift toward easygoing meals, and this place captures that feeling perfectly. Thin, ultra-crisp crusts and bold, flavorful toppings pair naturally with the relaxed vibe of Koloa and nearby Poipu. The dining room stays lively without ever feeling rushed, making it a reliable stop whether you're staying nearby or exploring different sides of the island.

Address: 5408 Koloa Rd, Koloa, HI 96756
Phone: (808) 431-4444
Island: Kauai

3. Flatbread Company — Paia, Maui

A swirl of oven smoke, organic produce, and North Shore character defines this longtime Paia favorite. The pizzas showcase Maui-grown ingredients from farms that stretch across Upcountry, Haiku, and Kula, grounding each dish in the agricultural backbone of the island. Diners relaxing in Paia appreciate how effortlessly this restaurant blends artisan technique with the casual rhythm of North Shore living.

Address: 89 Hana Hwy, Paia, HI 96779
Phone: (808) 579-8989
Island: Maui

4. Pizza Momo — Honolulu, Oahu

A stroll through China Town on the island of Oahu always reveals new culinary ideas, and this modern pizzeria thrives in that creative environment. The flavors lean inventive, the sauces stay balanced, and the crust arrives crisp with just enough bite to carry the toppings. Its location makes it easy for anyone exploring the Honolulu region to stop in for a memorable slice.

Address: 719 Kamehameha Hwy, Honolulu, HI 96817
Phone: (808) 762-0633
Island: Oahu

5. Fabiani’s — Kihei, Maui

South Maui’s warmth and casual lifestyle show up in every part of the Fabiani’s experience. Rustic Italian flavors blend seamlessly with the breezy Kihei atmosphere, creating pizzas that feel comforting without being heavy. The balanced crust, rich sauce, and thoughtful topping selections make it a favorite among residents throughout Kihei and nearby Wailea.

Address: 95 E Lipoa St, Kihei, HI 96753
Phone: (808) 874-1234
Island: Maui

6. Serpico’s Pizzeria — Pukalani, Maui

Upcountry Maui brings its own charm, and this Pukalani staple reflects that perfectly. The pizzas arrive hearty, flavorful, and clearly crafted with the kind of no-nonsense care that Upcountry residents appreciate. Many people stopping for a meal after time in Pukalani, Makawao, or Kula consider Serpico their go-to spot, especially for its generous portions and consistent execution. The crust leans classic and familiar, and the toppings feel honest and satisfying without trying too hard.

Address: 7 Makawao Ave, Pukalani, HI 96768
Phone: (808) 572-8498
Island: Maui

7. Brick Oven Pizza — Kalaheo, Kauai

Kauai families have relied on this spot for decades. The atmosphere stays nostalgic in all the right ways, and the pizzas come out hearty and full of flavor. Generous toppings, a classic American style, and a welcoming dining room keep it a reliable standby for visitors returning to the South Shore or West Side.

Address: 2-2555 Kaumualii Hwy, Kalaheo, HI 96741
Phone: (808) 332-8561
Island: Kauai

8. Cafe Pesto Hilo Bay — Big Island

Waterfront dining in Hilo has its own gentle rhythm, and this restaurant leans into that with pizzas built on thoughtful ingredients and clean, balanced flavors. Each dish reflects the slower pace of East Hawaii, especially when enjoyed with views across the bay. The crust holds up to ambitious combinations while still feeling light enough for a relaxed lunch or dinner.

Address: 308 Kamehameha Ave, Hilo, HI 96720
Phone: (808) 969-6640
Island: Hawaii Island

9. Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina — Lahaina, Maui

Italian craftsmanship shines in every part of the menu, from the methodically prepared dough to the curated toppings. Sale Pepe remains a respected West Maui standout, especially as the Lahaina community rebuilds and redefines itself. Diners staying in nearby areas like Kaʻanapali or Napili often consider this one of the essential dining stops.

Address: 878 Front St, Lahaina, HI 96761
Phone: (808) 667-7230
Island: Maui

10. Black Rock Pizza — Kona, Big Island

Kona’s coastal lifestyle comes through in the relaxed, no-frills charm of this local favorite. The pizzas arrive crisp, flavorful, and designed for sharing after a day exploring the west side of the island. It is simple, approachable, and consistently satisfying.

Address: 75-5595 Palani Rd, Kailua-Kona, HI 96740
Phone: (808) 326-1600
Island: Hawaii Island

11. Monkeypod Kitchen — Kaʻanapali, Maui

Kaʻanapali’s energetic dining scene finds one of its strongest offerings here. The wood-fired oven adds a gentle smokiness that elevates every pizza, and the toppings lean fresh and bold. Diners staying throughout Kaʻanapali and the surrounding resort areas often discover that the pizza rivals the restaurant’s already-famous entrées.

Address: 2435 Kaanapali Pkwy, Lahaina, HI 96761
Phone: (808) 878-6763
Island: Maui

Explore More of Hawaii’s Best Restaurants

Sampling the best pizza across Hawaii reveals just how diverse and creative island dining has become. Whether you're exploring the surf towns of Maui, the lush landscapes of Kauai, the energy of Honolulu, or the volcanic coastlines of the Big Island, each of these pizzerias reflects the flavor and spirit of its home community. If you want to go even deeper into Hawaii’s dining scene, our delicious guide to the best restaurants in Maui offers even more standout places to explore. If you are thinking about relocating, investing, or simply learning more about the neighborhoods surrounding these incredible destinations, our team is here to help you navigate the Maui real estate market with clarity and local insight. Reach out anytime to start exploring homes near your favorite island destinations.